Showing posts with label Aaron Sherman Watkins. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Aaron Sherman Watkins. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 21, 2020

Willard Dean Watkins










Willard Dean Watkins, February 14, 1931 (Canton, Ohio) -

VP candidate for Prohibition Party (2000)

Running mate with nominee: Earl F. Dodge (1932-2007)
Popular vote: 208 (0.00%)
Electoral vote: 0/538

The campaign:

Earl Dodge was making his fifth run for the Prohibition Party nomination and then the Presidency in 2000. But this time he almost didn't get past Step 1.

Dodge underwent a septuple bypass operation on May 28, 1999 but a month later was active in nabbing the Party's nomination at their convention. 39 Party members were present and a growing anti-Dodge faction had nominated a challenger, Gary Van Horn, a perennial candidate from Utah who had been the American Party VP nominee in 1996 and in 2000 was associated with the Independent American Party. Dodge defeated Van Horn in a close 9-8 vote.

The VP choice was W. Dean Watkins of Tucson, Ariz., a recent Party member with an interesting story. While researching his family history, he investigated the political career of his grandfather, Aaron S. Watkins. The elder Watkins had been the Prohibition Party VP nominee in 1908 and 1912, as well as the Presidential nominee in 1920. He also ran as a Prohibition Party candidate for the US House, US Senate, and Governor of Ohio. Discovering that the Party still existed, the grandson contacted Dodge and soon became the VP choice.

Some in the anti-Dodge faction felt the selection of Watkins was a publicity gimmick and the talents of this retired aeronautical engineer were not being used to full advantage. However, Watkins' precision and thoroughness was employed in his role as the chair of the committee to redraft and overhaul the Party's platform, and he wrote position papers.

As is turned out the 2000 platform changes were mostly cosmetic and it remained as consistently Right wing and bordering on Christian nationalism as it had been for decades. A few of the changes found in the 2000 platform worth noting--

Added under Taxation and Spending: Ending useless programs funded by the National Endowment for the Arts and the National Science Foundation -- Minimizing taxes which threaten private ownership of land and real estate -- Emphasizing excise taxes for the financing of government.

Added under Social Security: allowing workers the option of enrolling in private plans in lieu of Social Security;

At the very end The Alcohol Problem was completely rewritten and new section, Presidential Qualifications was added:

 The Alcohol Problem

Alcohol is still the number one drug problem in the United States. It is a major cause of poverty, traffic crashes, broken homes, juvenile and adult crime, physical and sexual abuse, political corruption, wasted manpower, disability, and premature death. We favor maintaining the nation-wide legal drinking age of 21.

  Historically, the Prohibition Party has led in offering programs of publicity, education, and legislation leading to the prohibition of the manufacturing, distribution, and sale of all alcoholic beverages. We continue to support this stand. Our society already practices prohibition in the form of enacting laws which promote the safety and well being of the society members. We will help Americans to realize that alcohol's harmful effects far outweigh those of all illegal drugs combined. We advocate that all tax monies collected from the sale of alcohol be used in aggressive media and educational campaigns to teach the American public the truth about alcohol. We support local option. We advocate the enactment and enforcement of strong drunk driving laws.


Presidential Qualifications

Leavening the Loaf
 "Nothing doth more hurt to a State than that cunning men pass for wise."
...Francis Bacon, statesman

The qualifications for President stated in the Constitution have to do with age and citizenship. We call attention to the fact that of greater importance are those not so stated referring to moral, intellectual, and spiritual endowments. The President of the United States in his daily life, his home and family relationships, and his official career is expected to typify the finest and best the country can produce. He is the leader of the nation. The moral force and power of his example are immeasurable.


Watkins wrote an essay entitled "Excise Taxes vs Income Taxes" and opened with the thesis statement: "The 2000 Prohibition Party platform advocates using excise taxes to pay for the operating costs of the federal government. It also advocates the abolishment of personal income taxes. Many people think this is a radical stand. However, let us examine the federal tax system ..."

On the ballot only in Dodge's home state of Colorado the Dodge/Watkins ticket placed dead last out of ten with 208 votes, 0.01% of the state total. Nationally they finished 15th out of 16 tickets on the ballot. This would be the worst result ever in the long history of the legitimate wing of America's oldest third party. 

In 2000 Dodge had faced rumblings within the Party, but it would explode into full revolution by the next election. Watkins joined the group that eventually ousted Dodge. In a 2002 article by Ernie Tucker, Watkins expressed his frustration: Concerns over fuzzy finances foamed over in 2000 ... Initially, Watkins supported Dodge's fifth presidential run, but he eventually grew frustrated with his lack of candor. "He's too secretive," Watkins says of Dodge. "His financial reports don't make sense. And there's an appearance of wrongdoing."

And this drama spilled over into the 2004 election.

Election history: none

Other occupations: US Army, Materials Testing Laboratory - Naval Avionics Center, design engineer at Hughes Aircraft Company, 

Notes:
Grew up in Canton, Ohio and Indianapolis, Ind.
Baptist.
Plays the piano and organ.

Tuesday, June 25, 2019

David Leigh Colvin






David Leigh Colvin, January 28, 1880 (South Charleston, Ohio) – September 7, 1959 (Bronxville, NY)

VP candidate for Prohibition Party (1920)

Running mate with nominee: Aaron S. Watkins (1863-1941)
Popular vote: 188,787 (0.71%)     
Electoral vote: 0/531

The campaign:

Sometimes you have to be careful what you ask for. After decades of effort, the Prohibition Party at last saw passage of the 18th Amendment and Prohibition becoming the law of the land.

Now what?

Their 1920 platform summarizes the purpose of their existence in a nutshell: "The issue is not only the Enforcement but also the Maintenance of the law to make the Amendment effective."

The platform took a stand on several other issues of the day, including: support for the League of Nations, increasing the role of women in government, creation of a Dept. of Education, and implementation of sex education in schools.

Presidential candidate Watkins offered to drop out of the race if Cox or Harding made a pledge not to weaken or repeal the Volstead Act. But response had he none. This backfired to some degree as the Prohibition Party found itself late in the campaign having to deny rumors that Watkins had indeed stepped down.

Ballot access by third parties was starting to become a problem as laws were changing to institutionalize the two-party system. The Prohibition Party, being the oldest of the third parties, makes a good case study for this. In 1920 their votes were recorded in only 26 states.

Their best three states were Florida (3.52%), California (2.67%), and Pennsylvania (2.30%). The Watkins/Colvin national result of 0.71% was the worst tally the Party had since 1880, and in all subsequent elections their final vote would never top 0.21%.

Election history:
1913 - New York State Assembly (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1914 - New York House of Representatives (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1916 - US Senate (NY) (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1917 - Mayor of New York City (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1922 - US House of Representatives (NY) (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1932 - US Senate (NY) (Law Preservation Party) - defeated
1936 - US President (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1947 - Prohibition Party nomination for US President - defeated

Other occupations: Army Captain WWI, speaker with Flying Squadron Foundation, Chairman of the Prohibition National Committee 1926-1932, author

Buried: Summit Lawn Cemetery (Westfield, Ind.)

Notes:
One of his opponents in the 1916 US Senate race was Socialist Labor candidate August Gillhaus,
 who he would later compete with for US Vice-President in 1920.
Earned a Ph.D. in political science from Columbia University in 1913.
His wife Mamie White Colvin also ran for various offices as a Prohibition Party candidate and was
 President of the Woman's Christian Temperance Union 1944-1953. They were considered something
 of a fervent power couple in the prohibition movement.
Methodist.
Unknown if he was related to Industrial Reform Party 1888 VP nominee John A. Colvin (1841-1900)
 who was also from the same region of Ohio.

Friday, June 14, 2019

Aaron Sherman Watkins











Aaron Sherman Watkins, November 29, 1863 (Rushsylvania, Ohio) – February 9, 1941 (Rushsylvania, Ohio)

VP candidate for Prohibition Party (1908, 1912)

Running mate with nominee (1908, 1912): Eugene W. Chafin (1852-1920)
Popular vote (1908): 254,087 (1.71%)
Popular vote (1912): 208,156 (1.38%)    
Electoral vote (1908): 0/483
Electoral vote (1912): 0/531

The campaign (1908):

Legal prohibition of alcohol across state and local jurisdictions had taken a dramatic rise since the 1904 election.

CSA Army veteran Rev. William B. Palmore who had failed to gain the presidential nomination was given the VP nod, but he declined, opening the way for Aaron S. Watkins.

The first two planks of the 11-point party platform dealt with alcohol, but among the remaining policies were: The election of United States Senators by direct vote of the people, Equitable graduated income and inheritance taxes, The strict enforcement of laws instead of official tolerance and practical license of the social evil which prevails in many of our cities with its unspeakable traffic in girls, The prohibition of child labor in mines, workshops, and factories, and finally most interesting and curious of all-- Legislation basing suffrage only upon intelligence and ability to read and write the English language.

The 1908 election had a funny symmetry that perhaps only those of us who enjoy trivia would notice. In a way there were three contests taking place. 1-- The two Williams, Taft vs. Bryan. 2-- The two Eugenes, Debs vs. Chafin. 3-- The two guys named Thomas, Hisgen vs. Watson.

The Prohibition Party placed 4th nationally in a race with up to seven parties on the presidential ballot.

Presented as an option in all but six states, the Chafin/Watson ticket had their best showing in South Dakota where they placed third with 3.52%. They also made third place in Michigan, Pennsylvania, Indiana, West Virginia, Iowa, Nebraska, Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, and Kentucky. This would be their 4th best presidential election.

The campaign (1912):

The Chafin/Watkins ticket was offered a second time, a testimony to the leadership abilities of both gentlemen within the Party. But 1912 would be one of the wildest presidential elections, making it more difficult for the Prohibition Party to fight for attention.

The introduction to the 1912 platform demonstrated the Prohibition Party's view of the role of alcohol being the cause of many social problems.

"The alcoholic drink traffic is wrong; is the most serious drain on the wealth and resources of the nation; is detrimental to the general welfare and destructive of the inalienable rights of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. All laws taxing or licensing a traffic which produces crime, poverty and political corruption, and spreads disease and death should be repealed. To destroy such a traffic there must be elected to power a political party which will administer the government from the standpoint that the alcoholic drink traffic is a crime and not a business, and we pledge that the manufacture, importation, exportation, transportation and sale of alcoholic beverages shall be prohibited."

The remainder of the 1912 platform was similar to the 1908 version except the literary test for suffrage was deleted. Added to the revised document was: Suffrage for women on the same terms as for men, and, A presidential term of six years, and one term only.

The Party placed 5th nationally, with their tally recorded in all but 8 states their best showings were in Florida (3.65%) and California (3.45%). Vermont and Delaware were the only two states where they outpolled the Socialists.

Election history:
1904 - US House of Representative (Ohio) (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1905 - Governor of Ohio (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1916 - US Senate (Ohio) (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1920 - President of the United States (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1922 - Governor of Ohio (Prohibition Party) - defeated
1928 - Prohibition Party nomination for US President - defeated
1932 - Governor of Ohio (Prohibition Party) - defeated

Other occupations: President of Asbury College 1909-1910, Methodist minister, attorney, teacher,

Buried: Equality Cemetery (Rushsylvania, Ohio)

Notes:
The second time a third party ran the same ticket two elections in a row, the first being Debs-Hanford
 (Socialist) 1904-1908.
Grandfather of 2000 Prohibition Party VP nominee Willard Dean Watkins.
Held the rank of Captain during WWI while an instructor at Miami Military Institute (Germantown,
 Ohio)
Was preparing to run for Governor of Ohio when nominated as VP in 1908, so he withdrew from the
 gubernatorial campaign.
Debated Clarence Darrow on the subject of prohibition of alcohol in Oshkosh, Wis. on Aug. 30,
 1909.